Jack L. Stotts
"The Long Arm of Forgiveness"
 
Program #3421
First broadcast March 3, 1991
 


     
Biography
Dr. Jack Stotts is President of Austin Presbyterian Theological Seminary in Austin, Texas. He served for a decade as President of McCormick Theological Seminary in Chicago. A native of Dallas, Dr. Stotts received his theological training at McCormick Seminary, Yale and Oxford University. Prior to taking on the presidency of McCormick in 1975, he pastored churches in Connecticut and in Texas and served as Chaplain at the University of Tulsa.  [Biographical information is correct as of the broadcast date noted above.]

"The Long Arm of Forgiveness" 

Two verses from Isaiah:

"Behold the Lord's hand is
not shortened, that it cannot save,
Or his ear dull, that it cannot hear;
But your iniquities have made a
separation
Between you and your God,
And your sins have hid his face from you."
Isaiah 59:1, 2.
I remember vividly a woman who only remembered the last one of those verses. "Your iniquities have made a separation/between you and your God." The year was 1960. The place was Big Spring, Texas, the state hospital for the mentally ill. I was a young pastor who had driven one hundred miles to see this person who was a member of my church.

I was in the visitor's lounge as Mrs. Ross came in, ferried by an attendant. As she entered, her restless eyes moved from object to object in the room, finally coming to rest, not looking at me, but looking at the floor. She was wearing a plain, loose fitting dress -- what we use to call a housedress; her hair seemed a stranger to a comb and brush, her hands would not cease that restless kneading.

Even as she inched towards me, I felt her spirit fleeing in the opposite direction. She did sit down. When she sat down, her posture resembled nothing so much as that of a cowed dog, afraid of what might happen in this encounter. I will never forget it.

I did not know what to say. All my pastoral care learnings drained away. I mumbled who I was, her pastor. But she only went farther away from me. I tried a different track. "How are you?" I asked, intending words that would caress, not attack her. Yet another retreat, another withdrawal. I heard her mumble, "I can't be forgiven; I've done the unpardonable sin, the unforgivable sin. I can't be forgiven."

Then she stood up. I did so as well. I reached out to put a reassuring arm around her shoulder, while saying the only thing that came to my mind: "God loves you." And then she came to life, lashing out at me. "Didn't you hear me!" she said, "I've committed the unforgivable sin! I can't be forgiven!" And then tears welled up from wells of loneliness, anger, despair and guilt.
The attendant came to take her away, her body tremoring with sobs, her eyes weeping. I did not know what to do nor what to say.

What had she done? What was it in the past that was so enormous that she felt she could not be forgiven? The doctor told me later no one had been able to discern that. But this much was clear. So far, no arms had been long enough to reach her. No word had been kind or direct or wise enough to comfort her. No medication had been potent enough to heal her.

And I left. As I pressed against the steel bar of the door going out, all waves of feelings mixed together came to the surface. I remember them still: a sense of failure, a sense of frustration, a sense of sadness, a sense of relief to be leaving, frankly, as I went out into that hot, penetrating and purging sun. But I have never forgotten, though I never went back, the woman, Mrs. Ross, who said, "I've committed the unforgivable sin; I cannot be forgiven."

I knew the verse from Matthew's gospel upon which she anchored her feelings: "Whoever sins against the Holy Spirit will not be forgiven, either in this age or in the age to come." (Matthew 12:32) What that text fully means, I really do not know. But I wonder, what would I say to her now? Would it be any different? As I reflect about that, I also believe the situation that Mrs. Ross was in was an extreme case of a situation that many of us find ourselves in. We are in a situation where forgiveness has become a problem, not a remedy.

Listen to what other say about forgiveness and their lack of it. It is the parent who driving a car too fast has an accident and the son in the car is killed. "Can anyone -- can God -- forgive me?" the parent inquires.

Or it is the mother about her daughter, "I'll never forgive her. She has gone against everything I ever taught her. How could I forgive her?"

Or it is the parent about a child, "I will never forgive God for letting leukemia kill my child."

For these and maybe countless others, forgiveness has become a problem, not a remedy. When that happens, all things are turned upside down. Forgiveness is God's remedy. It is God's remedy for separation. It is God's remedy for brokenness. It is God's presence and power with us to restore broken relationships, to heal those who have been separated. It is God's presence with us in power to overcome what has come between us and God and others.

Remember the stories, the stories of the Bible about forgiveness. They are familiar, aren't they? There is the story about a father who welcomes home a renegade son, a prodigal son, and welcomes the son back into the home, overcoming separation, restoring brokenness. There is great joy for forgiveness has come to that house.

There is a story of a woman about to be stoned for adultery and Jesus writes in the dirt, "Let the one who is without sin cast the first stone." All walk away for they know themselves to be people all of whom need forgiveness to be reunited to a different way of life.

There is a thief on the cross who cries out at the very last of his life and who is promised a relationship of love called heaven, the eternity with God.

Finally and most powerfully, there is the story about a man on a cross who said of those who were his enemies, "Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do."

There is the powerful story. It tells us this: Forgiveness is God's remedy for brokenness. Forgiveness is God's power with us to overcome everything that separates us from God, from each other and from ourselves. Forgiveness is overcoming the separation that arises between individuals, between person and person, parent and child, between races and between nations. It is God overcoming our lack, our guilt, our pride and saying to us, "My arms are long enough to embrace you no matter what you have done or what you haven't done." God's power of forgiveness. God's arms are long enough to embrace you, to embrace me, no matter what we have done.

You see, I could not embrace Mrs. Ross. She would not let me. She would not let God embrace her. This is the secret. The only unforgivable sin is the sin of not accepting God's forgiveness. God is there with arms outstretched to forgive.

Maybe you have been hurt; maybe you hurt someone in years gone by and it is still a burden to you. There is a brokenness, a separation there. Listen, God's arms are long enough to reach back into the past to overcome the burden. Maybe you have been a person who has hidden in the depths of yourself an enmity, a hostility, to someone else. Listen, God's arms are long enough to reach back and down into the recesses of our being to forgive us, to restore us.

Maybe you have run from God to a distant land of self-centeredness. Listen, God's arms are long enough to bring you home again. For God's forgiveness is not a problem, it's a remedy for our brokenness, our separation one from another.

And that is why we pray daily:
Forgive us our sins, our debts, our trespasses -- as we forgive those
who sin against us.

That is, restore us to life together with our fellow human beings.

What would I say to Mrs. Ross now? The same thing I say to myself and to you. Your sins are forgiven. Go in peace. Love all people. Love God by the power of God's forgiveness.
 

Interview with Jack Stotts
Interviewed by David Hardin

David Hardin: Jack, it occurs to me the difficulty we have with forgiving some people is that we don't want to forgive them because we think they're not good people. What is the answer to that?

Jack Stotts: One of the answers is that none of us are probably worthy of the forgiveness of God. All of us need that forgiveness. We are brothers and sisters in needing that forgiveness. When it comes to being a person who forgives, we deal with other human beings just like ourselves. We all need forgiveness. We are all going to do wrong to each other and we all need each other's hand reaching out to give us that forgiving word.

Hardin: One of the struggles I had in my own life was when my wife became seriously ill and ultimately died. My children took it out on God. They had trouble forgiving God for this kind of behavior. I never felt I handled it very well. What is the answer to that?

Stotts: I think none of us would handle that very well. You are not alone in that. There is a sense in which that is healthy and God allows that to happen. We get angry at God. Job got angry at God, didn't he? It is in the frustration and the venting of anger that we hear the good word of God, that He loves all people, including those who are your loved ones, no matter what their condition, whether in life or in death. That is God's word which comforts us all.

Hardin: I think it is important to remember that God can handle that.

Stotts: That's right.

Hardin: It's not a big deal.

Stotts: It's a big deal for us, though, isn't it? For God it is something that is part of God's own heart. At least that is the way I think it is.

Hardin: It's been wonderful having you with us. Thanks a lot.
  


 

Home | History | Program Schedule | This Week | Sermons | Publications | Related Links | Contact Us