John Buchanan
"Life's Second Question"
 
Program #3804
First air date October 24, 1994

Read the text 
.


     
Biography
The Rev. Dr. John Buchanan was born in Pennsylvania and received his theological education at the University of Chicago Divinity School. For 10 years, John was pastor of Broad Street Presbyterian Church in Columbus, Ohio, which under his leadership was cited by U.S. News and World Report as one of five "model congregations" in America. He has been Senior Pastor of Chicago’s historic Fourth Presbyterian Church since 1985. In 1996, he was elected to a one-year term as Moderator of the Presbyterian Church (USA), that denomination’s highest office. John is Editor and Publisher of The Christian Century, one of America’s finest journals of religious news and commentary. [Biographical information is correct as of the broadcast date noted above.]

"Life's Second Question"
The great philosopher, Immanuel Kant, said that there are three basic questions in life: "What can we know? What must we do? And what can we hope for?"

I'm not sure he had Immanuel Kant in mind, but one of our very distinguished Biblical scholars and teachers, Walter Wink, put that even more powerfully. Walter Wink said:

"The fundamental question for the first half of our pilgrimage is `what is the meaning of my life?' The question for the second half is, 'With the time I have left, how can I make a difference?'"

Life's second question -- "What must we do? With the time I have left, how can I make a difference?"

Sometimes life puts that question to us urgently. The late Arthur Ashe was a world champion tennis player, captain of America's Davis Cup Team, who in the course of heart surgery, contracted AIDS from a blood transfusion. As his disease progressed and he was dying, he wrote a wonderful book, Days of Grace.

After his first by-pass surgery and the decision to retire from playing tennis in 1979, Arthur Ashe experienced a sense of uneasiness and restlessness. He reflected:

"How could I be dissatisfied, even subtly, with my life to that point? I had lived a fantasy of a life. But I was dissatisfied. Who knows what force gnaws at us, telling us that our accomplishments, no matter how sensational, are not enough, that we need to do more? I wanted to make a difference, however small, in the world."

Life's second question. Immanuel Kant, speaking out of the dim past, Walter Wink from a modern classroom, and Arthur Ashe, in the middle of an unplanned, unexpected collision with his own mortality. They all sound like a young man who one day came to Jesus and asked, "Teacher, what good deed must I do to have eternal life?" He'd obviously been thinking about that a lot, too.

As the story is told in scripture, he's a very attractive young man. Jesus looked at him and loved him. He was so earnest, so sincere, so hard working, so purposeful, so successful.

What must I do to inherit eternal life? Life's second big question. There's apparently something gnawing at this young person, and who doesn't know what that feels like?

He's got it all: great job, good friends, lots of travel. He has a promising future and a growing portfolio with his broker. But there is this gnawing disease, this middle of the night dissatisfaction. What more must I do?

As the story is told in the bible, Jesus doesn't condemn or even criticize the young man. In fact, he appreciates him. When he tells the young man to follow the religious rules, to keep on keeping on, and the young man assures him that he's already doing that, Jesus prescribes something specific. He tells him something further to do. And what he tells that young man is stunning. "Sell your possessions, give the money to the poor, and come follow me." One modern scholar, commenting on that text, said if you aren't appalled by this message, you have not yet heard it.

The young man, Matthew explains, went away sad because he was wealthy, he had many possessions. He was appalled. I can understand that. I'm appalled too. Who isn't? Sell everything? Give it all away? You and I live in a culture that promises us, and our children, that you can buy life. You can establish happiness and security if you earn enough, have enough, accumulate enough. We live, that is to say, in what is now being called a "consumer culture."

The trouble is, consumer culture does not deliver on its promise to provide happiness, and, in fact, there is a sense in which a consumer culture works to the detriment of those very institutions which can - family, schools, non-profit public organizations, churches, mosques, synagogues. Cornell West, a professor at Harvard, whose fine new book, Race Matters, looks evenly and intelligently at the malaise of racism, poverty, unemployment and the escalating violence in which we find ourselves, in a recent interview said that when a market economy -- which we all now know is in some way necessary -- when a market economy becomes a market culture, mediating institutions that hold us together start to deteriorate. And why not? Why wouldn't they? Why wouldn't family and school and church deteriorate if the philosophic, spiritual drive behind the culture is greed or selfishness?

Jesus did not condemn this young man. He had a wonderful opportunity to launch a diatribe against success and its rewards but he did not take the opportunity. He did not condemn the young man's wealth. He apparently loved this young man.

What's wrong with him? Well, he's not free, for starters. He was already in bondage. His inability to sell all means that what he had actually owned him. I'll bet this young man was too busy to enjoy his life. I'll bet this young man had worked so hard to get ahead, he couldn't even remember what "ahead" meant. I'll bet the task of securing what he had and scurrying to keep up with inflation, was so important to him that he had no time left, no love, no passion in life.

And I think that's why he came to Jesus. He was, in fact, engaged in a struggle for his own soul. And for him the prescription was surgical: Let it go -- give it away -- and come follow me.

I think the most reassuring part of this great story is that Jesus' disciples themselves were amazed by what they were hearing, and they asked him, "Then who can be saved?" They weren't wealthy. They had given up about as much as it is possible to give, and yet they knew in their heart of hearts that they still loved what they had.

Arthur Ashe wrote, "I'm glad I have enough money to live comfortably. I decided long ago that, on the whole, I much prefer having money to not having it. On the other hand, I also learned a long time ago what money can and cannot do for me. From what we get we make a living. What we give, however, makes a life."

I found Arthur Ashe's memoir touching because he experienced and wrote about, in a compressed period of months, the human condition. Most of us, thank God, don't have that necessity. And yet, we are not here forever. We have only so many chances to make a difference.

When Arthur Ashe made public announcement of his condition, at first he became angry, depressed; and then, after about three weeks, his anger began to subside and the idea of AIDS and what it meant about the future began to integrate with the rest of his life, and he wrote at that time, "You come to the realization that time is short. These are extraordinary conditions. You have to step up. How much time I had left, I did not know. However, I could not ignore the fact that AIDS, as well as heart disease, was exacting a heavy toll on my body, and I had no time to waste."

And so Arthur Ashe began to speak out on the topic of AIDS: how you get it, how to keep from getting it, and how urgent it is for all of us in this country to understand the terrifying prospect of this epidemic continuing unabated. And Arthur Ashe opened his heart and his resources and established a Foundation for the Defeat of AIDS, and an association for African American-Athletes, and an Institute for Urban Health at the State University of New York, and a chair in Pediatric AIDS Research at St. Jude's Hospital, Memphis; and he became more vocal and active politically, protesting U.S. policy on Haitian refugees and once even getting arrested at the White House.

And he wrote, "As I settled into this new stage of life I became increasingly conscious of an exhilaration. I felt pain, but also something like pleasure in responding purposefully, vigorously. I had lost many matches on the tennis court, but I had seldom quit. I was losing, but playing well now: my head was down, my eyes riveted on the ball, I had to be careful but I could not be tentative."

And it seemed to me, reading this graceful book and thinking about what it means to be alive and well, with an opportunity to make a difference, it seemed to me that Arthur Ashe had in fact discovered his answer to life's second question and that you and I might pay careful attention.

At the end of the book, not very long before he died, he wrote, "I am a fortunate man. Aside from AIDS and heart disease, I have no problems."

There are opportunities every day to make a difference. How sad to miss them. It is our deepest trust that our ultimate destiny is in the gracious hands of a loving God.

Life, your capacity to make a difference, to love and work and care, to participate in and to empower, and to support institutions that bring healing and hope to others -- your fulfillment and purpose and even your happiness, all of that is in your hands.

Life's second question. What must I do?

Interview with John Buchanan
Interviewed by Lydia Talbot

Lydia Talbot: John, in your earlier message you discerned the difference between the rich man who is owned by his possessions, and the tennis star, Arthur Ashe, who died from AIDS from a blood transfusion, who nevertheless uses and shares his wealth for the common good. How is that understanding reflected in the vision and the witness and your leadership of the Fourth Presbyterian Church, which stands there surrounded by the icons of the consumer culture you talk about?

John Buchanan: Lydia, Presbyterianism particularly has always seen the Christian faith as a dynamic involved in the life of the world in some exciting and important way. To be a part of the culture that we are at the moment is to have to come to terms in some way with materialism, with the fabulous wealth that our culture and economy has generated. I am intrigued by Arthur Ashe's learning what I think is one of the basic messages of the Christian faith and that is, we are given resources to be used, there is, in fact, greater joy in giving than in getting, and there is something about the purpose of human life that is affirmed, finally, when we learn that lesson and literally give ourselves away. Ashe did that, of course, dramatically and tragically, but also heroically, I think, and in that sense is a model for Christian churches and for life in general.

Talbot: But a metaphor, too, for resources shared, that difference that you bring out between the market economy and the market culture, in other words. Well, what is that about in the urban ministries of Fourth Presbyterian Church?

Buchanan: Fourth Presbyterian Church, as you know, sits on Michigan Avenue in the middle of department stores and boutiques and theatres, and I think we stand as a reminder to the world, to ourselves, but also to our neighbors, that the purpose of life, the greatest and highest meaning of human life, is in the giving and loving and investing yourself in the life of others. The church tries to express that in its mission outreach programs. We are invested deeply in the lives of our neighbors, not only our affluent neighbors, but other neighbors who are not so affluent. We sponsor tutoring programs and counselling programs and programs designed to touch the lives of street people and hungry people around us.

Talbot: And the whole -- the use of place, of physical place, as a resource for the community. Students come every day from Cabrini Green Housing Projects into the building of Fourth Presbyterian Church for those kinds of experiences.

Let me ask you, it's a long way from Altoona, Pennsylvania, where you were born, to the University of Chicago Divinity School, to your status as one of the major Protestant leaders in this country. What was your journey all about and your inspiration to the ministry?

Buchanan: I have always been intrigued with the notion of a public church, and I think I was intrigued with that before I had a name for it, but it is the Church of Jesus Christ in whatever denomination or form, engaged in a dynamic and creative relationship with its neighbors, whether that's during the Second World War in Germany when Dietrich Bonhoeffer formed the Confessing Church and encountered Nazism, or the heroic stance of American Christianity in the time of Civil Rights or today, Fourth Presbyterian Church, I think, trying to be faithful and make its witness where it is. I have been intrigued consistently with this notion that we are called as a church, but also as individuals, to live faithfully and generously and compassionately as deeply as we can in the life of the world.

Talbot: Who made a difference in your life? There must have been something that turned you in the direction of ministry and your call.

Buchanan: One has to say one's parents, and that congregation which nurtured me as a child. I was also inspired deeply by the example of a man whose name I mentioned, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, whose witness was in the 30's and who died, as you know, in the concentration camp, or in prison. Also, Martin Luther King combined theology, political astuteness and this notion that it is the mission, the vocation of a Christian, to be involved in the life of the world.

Talbot: Your leadership skills were apparent as Chair of a Committee for the Reimagining Conference on feminine images of God which, as you say, nearly split the Presbyterian Church. How did you begin to approach that kind of mediation?

Buchanan: My task was to simply be the enabler, to be the moderator of a group of strangers who had never met before, but who came together to deal with that problem for the Presbyterian Church. My approach and my hope was that in the heart of most rational Presbyterians was a deep desire to see their church stay together, to respect one another, to listen for the truth that we all have and that is essentially what we were able to do, Lydia, to let people from around the country speak to an issue that had great potential for harm for the church, and in that process learn to respect one another and come to a position that at least accommodated the diversity within our community.

Talbot: Now, you have referred to the "core" that now has a voice. What does that mean?

Buchanan: Someone coined the phrase "culture wars" to describe what's going on in our nation, our culture at this time, that same split between conservative and liberal advocates occurs also in all our institutions and in the church. Often times the middle doesn't have its voice and feels that its task is simply to keep the left and the right talking to one another. My notion is that there is an authentic voice from the center, and it is liberal and it is also conservative and in point of fact, it is very important for the existence of all our institutions for that middle to find its voice and to be willing to articulate it.

Talbot: Now, you are given inspiration, I know, by many contemporary writers. You've mentioned some of them. Who are you going to read next week?

Buchanan: Oh, my. I read as much John Updike as I can. I've been very taken by Annie Proulx's new book, as a matter fact, and I'm going to keep reading through it. Shipping News is the name of it.

Talbot: And Updike especially.

Buchanan: Yes.

Talbot: What attracts you?

Buchanan: Updike has lived life thoroughly as people my age and my generation have. Updike has a fine theological sense, a fine theological ear. He is a pretty good lay theologian. I think he is respectful of the church and I think he mirrors back our culture in a way that's very important for us to hear.

Talbot: A combination of sensibilities that can be a lesson for all of us. John Buchanan, thank you so much.
  


 

Home | History | Program Schedule | This Week | Sermons | Publications | Related Links | Contact Us